I ve been reading and watching with interest a UK Channel 4 report on the popular virtual world Habbo Hotel . For those unfamiliar with the story, Channel 4 News got a female producer to pose as an 11-year old girl for 2 months, who complains that she was subjected to extreme sexual contact from other users. The report also hints strongly that some of the contact came from groomers and possibly paedophiles, and highlights the case of two teenagers who were contacted in Habbo Hotel, and later sexually abused.
The video is disturbing to say the least, some of the exchanges leave nothing to the imagination, and it seems clear that Sulake , the makers of Habbo Hotel, have a serious problem with supervision and moderation on their hands. However, I have been rather puzzled discount rental car by the coverage. This has clearly brought out the Think of the Children and Ban This Filth crowds, all baying for virtual blood. The game has been universally condemned, and even the European Union has warned Sulake that they must take action, or face regulatory intervention.
Habbo Hotel is not really a game, it is a gathering place, a virtual chat room with 230 million users worldwide where teenagers and children choose avatars and interact with one another. That in itself makes it tremendously difficult to regulate, the site has 70 million lines of conversation every day, which makes even the most basic attempt at moderation an expensive and impossible task. Software could perhaps help flag some inappropriate conversations, discount rental car but with that amount of volume, it could prove to be impossible.
What is happening with Habbo Hotel is not new, it is as old as virtual spaces. Some of the descriptions of virtual sex acts in the video reminded me of Dibbell s famous discount rental car Rape in Cyberspace . The question of moderation is at the heart of online spaces. In my experience, many unmoderated spaces online usually descend into abuse, porn, misogyny, homophobia and racism. The perception of anonymity really tends to bring out the worst in some people, proving once more Penny Arcade s Greater Internet F*ckwad Theory . Moreover, many game companies and virtual world designers are caught in what could be called the moderation dilemma, if they ban too many users, that will affect their profits. So for many years now I have witnessed game chartrooms where no moderation exists. In some cases, this makes gaming experience rather painful, and normal people either migrate, or turn it off completely, which leaves all public spaces to the trolls, perpetuating censurable behaviour.
I am also interested to try to find out how much of the objectionable chat in Habbo Hotel is the norm, and comes from the teenage users themselves, or if it is a journalistic exaggeration. I have never liked virtual gathering places such as Habbo or Second Life, I find them boring, but Channel 4 must have kept records of what transpired, perhaps chat logs, or something similar. If the site is filled with filth as they present, then I would not be surprised, but it would certainly merit some sort of action.
discount rental car The problem discount rental car here is that even if Habbo gets its act together, it is perfectly possible that teenagers will migrate to other free spaces. A large percentage discount rental car of male tweens and teenagers already inhabits completely distributed games such as Minecraft . In Minecraft, people who have bought the game can run their own server, making it literally impossible to control. For a generation that is growing up suspicious of all control, such distributed solutions are the way of the future.
About the blog TechnoLlama covers several Cyberlaw topics, discount rental car with emphasis on open licensing, discount rental car digital rights, software protection, discount rental car virtual worlds, and llamas. While the blog tackles these issues in a light-hearted and nonchalant manner, some serious points filter through from time to time.
Tags Select Tag Academia ACTA Announcements Apple blogg Blogging Book Cases Censorphip Conferences Copyright Creative Commons Cybercrime Cybersecurity Digital music Digital rights Dispute Resolution DRM e-commerce discount rental car Enforcement Español Facebook Feeling silly Games Globalisation discount rental car Governance Hacking Litigation Meme Microsoft Networks New technologies Open content Open hardware Open source P2P Patent abuse Popular Culture Privacy Regulation Reviews SCRIPT-ed Social media Software patents Spam Standards Technophobia discount rental car Travel Virtual worlds Web 2.0 Wikileaks Categories
Recent Comments Jess Wallace on Unfortunate name for rip off Brad Knight on Doctor Who: Partners in Copyright Crime Brad Knight on Doctor discount rental car Who: Partners in Copyright Crime Digital Music is Creating the New Music Industry discount rental car Standard Yahoo! Voices voices.yahoo.com The Urban Link on The lost decade of digital music sales The REAL Death Of The Music Industry Business Insider | My Musical Talent on The lost decade discount rental car of digital music sales Licence Technollama by Andres Guadamuz is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Costa Rica License
No comments:
Post a Comment